6 Best Decorative Buttons For Attaching Pompoms To Hats
Discover the 6 best decorative buttons for attaching pompoms to hats. Learn how to combine style and functionality for a secure, removable finish every time.
Adding a removable pompom to your hand-knit hat is the ultimate upgrade for both style and practicality. By using a sturdy button, you ensure your pompom stays secure during wear but detaches easily for laundering. This simple hardware choice transforms a delicate accessory into a long-lasting, functional garment. Let’s explore the best button options to elevate your next project.
Dritz Extra Large Toggle Buttons for Pompoms
If you want a pompom that sits firmly atop your hat without wobbling, a toggle button is your best friend. These are substantial pieces of hardware designed to withstand the tension of a heavy faux-fur pompom.
The elongated shape provides a distinct mechanical advantage over standard flat buttons. Because the toggle is long, the elastic loop of the pompom can be stretched over it with ease, yet it won’t slide off accidentally while you’re walking in the wind.
These toggles are often made of durable plastic or wood, making them lightweight enough not to drag down the crown of your hat. For heavier, oversized yarn pompoms, the toggle’s length is a massive benefit.
Buttons Galore & More Shank Buttons Selection
Shank buttons are the gold standard for those who want a clean, professional finish on the inside of the hat. Unlike flat buttons, these feature a small loop on the back, allowing the fabric to sit flush against the hat’s interior.
When you use a shank button, you avoid the bulk that often builds up when sewing a flat button directly through the crown. This is vital if your hat is a tight-fitting beanie, as it prevents the hardware from pressing uncomfortably against the top of your head.
Look for metal or high-quality resin shanks that have smooth edges. A sharp or rough shank can eventually fray your yarn, so always run your thumb over the loop before sewing it onto your precious hand-knit fabric.
La Mode Rustic Wood Buttons for Winter Hats
Wood buttons add a beautiful, organic touch to wool hats, especially those knit in earthy, neutral tones. They provide a high-contrast, artisanal look that signals the garment is handmade with care.
However, keep in mind that natural wood can be porous. If you live in a climate with heavy snow or frequent rain, ensure the wood is finished or sealed to prevent it from absorbing moisture and potentially staining your yarn.
These buttons are generally lightweight, which is a significant plus for delicate lace-weight or fingering-weight hats. If you choose wood, opt for a button with a smooth, polished surface to protect your yarn from snagging.
JHB International Novelty Heart Shape Buttons
Novelty buttons are a fun way to add a hidden "easter egg" to your knitting. While they might seem purely decorative, a heart-shaped button can actually act as a clever anchor point for a pompom loop.
Because these buttons are often flat, they sit very close to the fabric. They are ideal for children’s hats or gifts where you want a whimsical touch that isn’t immediately obvious to the casual observer.
Always check the size of the heart’s "indents." If the button is too intricate, the elastic loop of your pompom might get snagged or stretched out of shape over time. Stick to heart shapes with rounded, smooth edges to maintain the integrity of your pompom’s elastic.
Jesse James Dress It Up Seasonal Button Packs
These thematic button packs are perfect for makers who enjoy holiday-specific knitting. They offer a variety of sizes and textures in a single pack, allowing you to experiment with different looks for different hats.
The trade-off here is durability; some novelty packs are made of lighter-weight plastic intended for scrapbooking rather than garment wear. If you go this route, test the button’s strength by pulling on it firmly before sewing it to your hat.
These are excellent for projects that aren’t intended for heavy daily use, such as a festive Christmas bonnet. For everyday wear, ensure the button is securely attached with a strong, non-stretchy thread.
Benno’s Buttons Natural Coconut Shell Buttons
Coconut shell buttons are incredibly dense and durable, making them one of the most reliable choices for a permanent hat fixture. They have a unique, mottled appearance that looks stunning against hand-dyed wools.
Because they are a natural material, each button has slight variations in color and pattern. This adds to the "hand-crafted" aesthetic that many knitters strive for in their finished pieces.
They are naturally water-resistant and hold up well to the rigors of winter weather. If you want a button that will outlast the hat itself, coconut shell is an excellent investment.
Why Use Buttons Instead of Ties for Pompoms
Many beginners start by tying their pompoms directly to the hat using the yarn tails. While this is free, it makes washing the hat a nightmare, as you have to untie and retie the pompom every time.
Using a button creates a "plug-and-play" system. You simply sew a button to the inside or outside of the crown, and your pompom becomes a removable accessory.
This extends the life of your pompom, which often loses its fluffiness if it goes through the wash. A buttoned pompom stays looking fresh and bouncy for years.
Choosing the Right Button Size for Your Hat
The size of your button should be proportional to the weight of your pompom. A tiny button will not hold a large, heavy faux-fur pompom, and a massive button will feel like a heavy weight on your head.
Aim for a button diameter between 15mm and 25mm for most standard-sized pompoms. If the button is too small, the elastic loop will slip off; if it’s too large, you’ll struggle to stretch the loop over it.
Always consider the "depth" of the button as well. A button that is too flat might be hard to catch with your fingers, while a very deep toggle might catch on your hair. Always match the button size to the diameter of your pompom’s elastic loop.
How to Securely Attach Buttons to Knit Fabric
Never sew a button directly to a single layer of knit fabric, as it will eventually pull through or cause the fabric to sag. Instead, use a small piece of felt or a "backing button" on the inside of the hat.
This backing button distributes the tension across several stitches, preventing the weight of the pompom from pulling a hole in your knitting. Use a strong, matching thread or a thin piece of nylon cord for maximum durability.
Pro-tip: Leave a tiny bit of "shank" space—about 2mm—between the button and the fabric. This gives the pompom loop enough room to sit comfortably without pulling the button tight against the knit stitches.
Essential Tips for Removable Pompom Care
When it’s time to wash your hat, always remove the pompom first. If you have a faux-fur pompom, shake it out vigorously and use a clean comb to fluff the fibers before reattaching it.
If your pompom is made of yarn, keep it in a separate mesh bag if you must wash it, though it’s usually better to just spot-clean it. Check the button attachment every few months to ensure the threads haven’t loosened.
A quick tug on the button before you head out the door is the best way to ensure your pompom stays on your hat and not on the sidewalk.
Choosing the right button for your pompom is a small detail that makes a world of difference in your knitting journey. By prioritizing durability and proper attachment, you ensure your handiwork remains both beautiful and functional. Take the time to secure your hardware properly, and your hats will be ready for many winters to come. Happy knitting, and may your pompoms always stay perfectly in place!
